The Indypendent
DONATE NOW - URGENT FALL 2009 FUNDRAISING CAMPAIGN
Search All Articles
Get The Indy by Email




Facebook Twitter

Donate

Subscribe

The IndyShop

RSS Available

Why we love The Indy






Sarah Stuteville
Journalism Workshops

Indykids

Posters!

A Threat to Peace
Artwork by The Indypendent Staff

A Threat to Peace - Artwork by The Indypendent

Buy Now! »


Army of None
Artwork by David Hollenbach

Army of None - Artwork by David Hollenbach

Buy Now! »


Community Resources

The Fake is Real

By Erica Patino
From the November 1, 2006 issue | Posted in Reviews | Email this article
borat
borat
After ten years of various incarnations on British television and on HBO’s Da Ali G Show, Borat Sagdiyev, the lusty Kazakhstani television reporter, stars in his own feature film, Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan.

British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen gives us a scathing mockumentary as Borat and his plump producer Azamat go to the United States on assignment from the Kazakh Ministry of Information to “learn lessons” that will be useful to their home country. Once he gets to America, Borat discovers a new mission: driving cross-country in an ice cream truck to make Pamela Anderson his wife.

The best and worst thing about Borat is that most of the interactions are unstaged. This makes for some hilarious hijacked sequences that will be no surprise to fans of Da Ali G Show. But misogyny, anti-Semitism, class and race issues make frequent appearances, presented alongside some ingenious physical gags.

High society, ghettos and rodeos all receive Borat with different levels of enthusiasm. When Borat goes into a gun shop and asks, “Which gun would be best to shoot the Jews?” the man behind the counter doesn’t miss a beat, recommending a 9-mm handgun. It’s funny because Borat is fake, awful because the store owner’s response is real.

Borat is not for those who are easily offended, but for audiences who enjoy fighting fire with fire, the movie offers some of the sharpest satire in recent film. You’ll laugh, you’ll flinch, and you’ll wonder how so many people could say such dumb things to an enthusiastic foreigner in a tattered gray suit.

This is a great movie to see in theaters, not just for the experience of laughing wildly together with strangers, but also because, as Borat’s Myspace page declares, “Please you come see November 3. If movie not success, I will be execute.” Hard to argue with that, isn’t it?

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Sphinn
  • Mixx
For nine years, The Indypendent has printed truth in the face of power. With political and economic systems faltering, there is an opportunity for real change from the bottom up. But this means having a vibrant independent media. Consider supporting The Indypendent as a monthly sustainer, donating as little as $5 a month. Please visit indypendent.org/donate.

Subscribe to the Indypendent!

Both comments and pings are currently closed.

14 Responses to “The Fake is Real”

limited irony Says:

Wow, that’s really funny – A British Jew makes fun of backwards, Muslim Central Asians.

They are so racist.

They are so narrow.

They are so homophobic.

They are so fucked up.

Not like us. We have a sense of humor. Not like them. They get touchy after endless racist bullshit directed at them. How narrow. How petty. How backwards. Not like us. We get the joke, what’s their problem? Right?

Think about who Sasha Baron Cohen doesn’t make fun of.

I guess it takes real “bravery” to mock third world peoples while they are getting the shit bombed out of them. Call it satire, but it’s essentially Amos ‘n Andy dressed up for the modern era. It’s an irreverent thread of the same racist cloth.

But I guess I’m “easily offended.”

Let’s see how a cariacture of a shyster Jew makes it in Hollywood. And then we’ll see who is “easily offended.” Oh, that’s right, I forgot – that movie won’t get made.

Can we at least expect a nominally left-wing newspaper to understand these points? Or is that too much to ask?

(by the way, racism isn’t about “taking offense.” It’s about who has the power to enforce social systems. The arrogance, imperial paternalism, and plain racism of the Anglo-American-Israeli power structure is really without comparison. Cultural propaganda that desinsitizes us to the humanity of other people is war propaganda. Sasha Baron Cohen is playing his loyal role…. with the audacity to act as if it is Muslims who have the real history of murderous anti-Semitism. Or that racism today isn’t OVERWHELMINGLY directed as Muslims, Arabs, Mexicans – and in Europe at the immigrant groups who fill the ranks of their lower classes.)

But hey, it’s funny right? All a joke, right?

Smug hipster racism is the same old shit.

Chanders Says:

Wow. You are uptight.

d Says:

i’m not so sure about that, but doesn’t the show reveal discrimination and stupidity among the ‘involved’ in the first place? i mean look at this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHRqe9L56t4

ok, you can discuss about the understanding of the audience. i don’t think that everybody will get the hint, that the funny thing are not the jokes about jews, but the antisemitic asshole who laughs about them.

also look at the ‘bruno’ thing: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G8Ec8J4erkU
people laughing about ‘acting gay’ are made fool of in this one.

uptight Says:

Chanders: What is your ethnicity?

Are you white?

I bet about a million dollars you are.

I am uptight for being sick of the constant stream of degredation that we get?

The day you have to put up with racist bullshit directed at YOUR people, while they are detained, tortured and cariactured as barbarians then let’s see how you like it.

http://counterpunch.org/atzmon11072006.html

“Smug hipster racism is the same old shit.”

“Not like us. We have a sense of humor. Not like them. They get touchy after endless racist bullshit directed at them. How narrow. How petty. How backwards. Not like us. We get the joke, what’s their problem? Right?”

Yeah, irony is so cool. So enlightened. So chill. So full of shit.

Not uptight Says:

Full disclosure: I am a conservative. I won’t even waste my time or yours explaining my views on the “is Borat inherently racist” debate. But man, is Chaders right. You ARE uptight. Also, your choppy sentence structure and sarcastic fictional quotes are both painful to read. I love how Chanders is guilty of the crime of (possibly) being white, so it invalidates anything else he might have to say in your book. I thought you ultra-lefties were supposed to be all about exchange of ideas. What gives?

Arunabh Chatterjee Says:

Limited IRONY’s post is better than the review itself. IRONY, your post is one of the best I have seen or read so far. Hit the bulls eye.

F_OFF Says:

Your statments about him being white and “betting a million that he is white” just proves that you your self have a racist point of view on all white people. Because he is white its his fault right, or maybe because he feels your worng he must be white right….You are soooo lame. And for the record i am NOT white. I am so sick of hearing ANY one complain about racist. If a white guy goes into a black comunity he is judged for being white, RACIST. If a black guy goes into a white community he is judged the same way, again RACIST. So this is something you have not figured out yet huh???….. well get used to it, any one pointing the finger and claiming they are the “correct” ones, then you are trully the ones that are keeping these issues alive. In ohter words, not helping just pointing your finger at some one else and saying its your fault, im perfect. Ever herd of the term, “cast the firts stone”. Think about it.

repost Says:

Borat film ‘tricked’ poor village actors
By BOJAN PANCEVSKI and CARMIOLA IONESCU, Mail on Sunday
Last updated at 21:25pm on 11th November 2006

When Sacha Baron Cohen wanted a village to represent the impoverished Kazakh home of his character Borat, he found the perfect place in Glod: a remote mountain outpost with no sewerage or running water and where locals eke out meagre livings peddling scrap iron or working patches of land.

But now the villagers of this tiny, close-knit community have angrily accused the comedian of exploiting them, after discovering his new blockbuster film portrays them as a backward group of rapists, abortionists and prostitutes, who happily engage in casual incest.

They claim film-makers lied to them about the true nature of the project, which they believed would be a documentary about their hardship, rather than a comedy mocking their poverty and isolation.

Villagers say they were paid just £3 each for this humiliation, for a film that took around £27million at the worldwide box office in its first week of release.

Now they are planning to scrape together whatever modest sums they can muster to sue Baron Cohen and fellow film-makers, claiming they never gave their consent to be so cruelly misrepresented.

Disabled Nicu Tudorache said: This is disgusting. They conned us into doing all these things and never told us anything about what was going on. They made us look like primitives, like uncivilised savages. Now they,re making millions but have only paid us 15 lei [around £3].

Cambridge-educated Baron Cohen filmed the opening scenes of the Borat movie in Glod - a village that is actually in Romania, rather than Kazakhstan, and whose name literally translates as ‘mud’, last summer.

Its 1,000 residents live in dilapidated huts in the shadow of the Carpathian mountains. Toilets are little more than sheltered holes in the ground and horses and donkeys are the only source of transport.

Just four villagers have permanent employment in the nearby towns of Pucioasa or Fieni, while the rest live off what little welfare benefits they get.

So when a Hollywood film crew descended on a nearby run-down motel last September, with their flashy cars and expensive equipment, locals thought their lowly community might finally be getting some of the investment it so desperately needs.

The crew was led by a man villagers describe as ‘nice and friendly, if a bit weird and ugly’, who they later learned was Baron Cohen. It is thought the producers chose the region because locals more closely resembled his comic creation than genuine Kazakhs.

The comedian insisted on travelling everywhere with bulky bodyguards, because, as one local said: ‘He seemed to think there were crooks among us.’

While the rest of the crew based themselves in the motel, Baron Cohen stayed in a hotel in Sinaia, a nearby ski resort a world away from Glod’s grinding poverty. He would come to the village every morning to do ‘weird things’, such as bringing animals inside the run-down homes, or have the village children filmed holding weapons.

Mr Tudorache, a deeply religious grandfather who lost his arm in an accident, was one of those who feels most humiliated. For one scene, a rubber sex toy in the shape of a fist was attached to the stump of his missing arm - but he had no idea what it was.

Only when The Mail on Sunday visited him did he find out. He said he was ashamed, confessing that he only agreed to be filmed because he hoped to top up his £70-a-month salary - although in the end he was paid just £3.

He invited us into his humble home and brought out the best food and drink his family had. Visibly disturbed, he said shakily: ‘Someone from the council said these Americans need a man with no arm for some scenes. I said yes but I never imagined the whole country, or even the whole world, will see me in the cinemas ridiculed in this way. This is disgusting.

‘Our region is very poor, and everyone is trying hard to get out of this misery. It is outrageous to exploit people’s misfortune like this to laugh at them.

‘We are now coming together and will try to hire a lawyer and take legal action for being cheated and exploited. We are simple folk and don’t know anything about these things, but I have faith in God and justice.’

If the village does sue the film-makers, they won’t be the first. Last week, two unnamed college students who were caught on film drunkenly making racist and sexist comments took legal action, claiming the production team plied them with alcohol and falsely promised that the footage would never be seen in America.

Many other unwitting victims of Baron Cohen’s pranks have also spoken out against the way they were conned and - unsurprisingly - the rulers of Kazakhstan have long taken issue with the image Borat paints of their vast, oil-rich nation.

The residents of Glod only found out about the true nature of the film after seeing a Romanian TV report. Some thought it was an art project, others a documentary.

The Mail on Sunday showed them the cinema trailer - the first footage they had seen from the film. Many were on the brink of tears as they saw how they were portrayed.

Claudia Luca, who lives with her extended family in the house next to the one that served as Borat’s home, said: ‘We now realise they only came here because we are poorer than anyone else in this village. They never told us what they were doing but took advantage of our misfortune and poverty. They made us look like savages, why would anyone do that?’

Her brother-in law Gheorghe Luca owns the house that stood in for Borat’s - which the film-makers adorned by bringing a live cow into his living room.

Luca, who now refers to Baron Cohen as to the ‘ugly, tall, moustachioed American man’, even though the 35-year-old comedian is British, said: ‘They paid my family £30 for four full days. They were nice and friendly, but we could not understand a single word they were saying.

‘It was very uncomfortable at the end and there was animal manure all over our home. We endured it because we are poor and badly needed the money, but now we realise we were cheated and taken advantage of in the worst way.

‘All those things they said about us in the film are terribly humiliating. They said we drink horse urine and sleep with our own kin. You say it’s comedy, but how can someone laugh at that?’

Spirea Ciorobea, who played the ‘village mechanic and abortionist’, said: ‘What I saw looks disgusting. Even if we are uneducated and poor, it is not fair that someone does this to us.’

He remembered wondering why the crew took an old, broken Dacia car and turned it into a horse cart. He said: ‘We all thought they were a bit crazy, but now its seems they wanted to show that it is us who drive around in carts like that.’

Local councillor Nicolae Staicu helped the crew with their shooting, but he claims he was never told what sort of movie they were making, and that they failed to get a proper permit for filming.

Staicu, who had never dealt with a film crew before, said: ‘I was happy they came and I thought it would be useful for our country, but they never bothered to ask for a permit, let alone pay the official fees.

‘I realise I should have taken some legal steps but I was simply naive enough to believe that they actually wanted to do something good for the community here.

‘They came with bodyguards and expensive cars and just went on with their job, so we assumed someone official in the capital Bucharest had let them film.’

Bogdan Moncea of Castel Film, the Bucharest-based production company that helped the filming in Romania, said the crew donated computers and TV sets to the local school and the villagers. But the locals have denied this.

Mr Staicu said: ‘The school got some notebooks, but that was it. People are angry now, they feel cheated.’

It’s a feeling Glod is used to. The village, like others in the Dambovita region of Romania, is populated mainly by gipsies who say they are discriminated against by the rest of the country.

Indeed, when local vice-mayor Petre Buzea was asked whether the people felt offended by Baron Cohen’s film, he replied: ‘They got paid so I am sure they are happy. These gipsies will even kill their own father for money.’

No one from the 20th Century Fox studio was available for comment on the villagers’ claims.

But feelings in Glod are running so high that The Mail on Sunday saw angry villagers brandishing farm implements chase out a local TV crew, shouting that they had enough of being exploited.

It is small comfort that few, if any, of them will get to see the Borat film. Not a single villager we spoke to had ever been able to afford a trip to the nearest cinema, 20 miles away.

Perhaps that’s the real reason why film-makers chose Glod in the first place.

Borat Says:

Wow, you really do show your true colors “betting” someone who has a different opinion than you that they are white. You claim that Muslims, Arabs, Mexicans, etc are the target of most racism, but you obviously have strong prejudices towards white people. But I guess that’s OK. It’s alright to lump all white folks in one category, but when a comedian plays a character you don’t like, you rant like an idiot.

If you had actually watched the movie, or even the HBO series for that matter, you would realize that the people Cohen interviews are meant to be the butt of the joke, not the people of Kazakhstan. Most people in the US have little knowledge of Kazakhstan or it’s culture. For that matter, Cohen could have picked any central Asian or eastern European country and still played the same character. He says offensive things to see how people react. In many cases he exploits the anti-semitic and racist feelings many people still harbor. In other cases he does it simply to get a rise out of people. See it for what it is and stop being such a sensitive clown.

Gaia Thomas Says:

I was, at first, curious about Borat. It sounded like brilliant comedy. But increasingly I began to suspect that it was xenophobic of people of Middle Eastern decent. Islam in Kazakhstan is the dominant religion of Kazakhs, the indigenous population of the country. By tradition the Kazakhs are Sunni Muslims of the Hanafi school.
Initially I thought Kazakhstan was a made up country. Jokes made at the expense of imaginary people I thought harmless. However, it does exist. Kazakhstan is bordered by Kyrgyzstan. When I was 15 I made friends with a girl, Narissa, from Kyrgyzstan. She danced around her room to Madonna and wore black lipstick like me. She did not wash her face in the toilet (as Borat is seen to do.)
In light of the devastation we wreaked in Afghanistan and Iraq, a film ridiculing Muslims is about as funny as a film mocking the Jews during the Holocaust. Its success as a #1 box office hit disturbs me.
We need to remember that we are a nation recovering from trauma. One reaction to the catastrophic violence of 9-11 has been a distorted view of people of Arab decent. The film\’s caricature of the Kazakhs plucks strings that resonate with that fear.
The humor in this film temporarily relieves tension. I think that\’s what blackface humor does: emboldens one and, for a moment, removes the pressure of constant fear. But it does not treat the wound, it exacerbates it.

Ron Says:

Most of the posts here are well written and clearly well thought out, but I think that a lot of people are missing the point of this movie. It is not an attack on Muslims or Middle-easterners. If anything, it is an attack on Americans. The character being middle-eastern only serves the purpose of maximizing the chance that he will be reacted-to strongly. Other than this, where Borat is from is irrelevant. I highly doubt that anyone who watches this movie will truly believe the Kazakhs drink out to toilets and have sex with their sisters. The depiction is so over-the-top that I can’t imagine anyone thinking that its true. Clearly no one on here did.

The only people who come out of the movie looking badly are the idiots who make racist comments in response to Borat. If there a complaint to be made, its that Cohen choose easy-targets and put people into situations in which they could only look bad. These people are far from an accurate cross-section of the American people, and the movie perpetuating the stereotype of the narrow-minded American.

Personally, I did not find it offensive, and I think if people just see the movie for what it is - a mockery of narrow-minded individuals - they won’t either

Christopher Dent Says:

Khazakstan is not a Muslim country….it is over 50% Christian…
wow, you guys are funny.

Jehan Says:

Borat is a Comedy. If you don’t agree with what he’s saying turn it off. I’m muslim and I get the joke, I don’t need people of other races and religions telling me its not funny, and racist when it is actually hilarious kudos to Mr. Cohen, for just getting it

azamat Says:

I LOVE THE MOVIE BORAT!!! IT’S HILLARIOUS!!!