The Indypendent
Jeremy Scahill"The best paper in New York City."
— Jeremy Scahill
Robert McChesney"A terrific newspaper that breaks the sort of stories those in power wish never saw the light of day." — Bob McChesney
Danny Schechter"A world newspaper of conscience" alongside Le Monde Diplomatique and the U.K. Guardian. — Danny Schechter
Naomi Klein"Utterly unique and just keeps getting better."
— Naomi Klein
DONATE NOW!
Search All Articles

 

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Sphinn
  • Mixx



RSS Available

Donate

Subscribe

The IndyShop

Why we love The Indy






Sarah Stuteville
Journalism Workshops

Indykids

Posters!

A Threat to Peace
Artwork by The Indypendent Staff

A Threat to Peace - Artwork by The Indypendent

Buy Now! »


Army of None
Artwork by David Hollenbach

Army of None - Artwork by David Hollenbach

Buy Now! »


Community Resources

Israeli Democracy: Arabs Need Not Apply

From the July 4, 2009 issue | Posted in International | Email this article

NAZARETH—Israel is frequently cited as “the only democracy in the Middle East.” The 1.2 million Palestinians living inside Israel’s borders, would beg to differ.

Beginning with the founding of Israel as a Jewish state in 1948, Palestinians have been treated as second-class citizens and enemies from within. Each of the “Basic Laws,” the foundation of the Israeli legal system, begins with a statement that Israel is a Jewish state. For example, the purpose of the Basic Law: Human Dignity and Freedom is “to establish the values of the State of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state.”

From 1948 until 1966, Palestinians inside Israel were subject to military law, while Jews lived under civilian law. During that time, 66 percent of Arab-owned land was confiscated. In 1947, Jews owned 6.7 percent while Palestinians held the rest. Today, Israeli Palestinians, 20 percent of the population, own 2.5 percent of the land.

Discrimination inside Israel falls broadly into four categories, according to Mohammad Zeidan, general director of the Nazareth- based Arab Association for Human Rights (AHR): laws that give different privileges and rights to Jews and non-Jews; indirect discrimination not specifically linked to religion; institutional discrimination, such as allocation of municipal funds; and racism in public life, including cultural discrimination.

The legal discrimination can be seen explicitly in laws that offer automatic Israeli citizenship to Jews from anywhere in the world, while non-Jews who are married to Israeli citizens face a difficult process for acquiring citizenship.

In order to be elected to the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, political parties must formally recognize Israel as a Jewish state, so even advocating complete equality for Palestinians inside Israel would disqualify a party from running candidates.

Legal discrimination also plays a role in land allocation. Nearly 20 percent of Israeli land is controlled by the Jewish National Fund, which is legally mandated to use the land only to benefit Jews. Much of this land was confiscated from its Palestinian owners by the military or taken away under the “absentee” laws of 1950, which declared that landowners who were not occupying their land in the years 1948 to 1952 forfeited their rights to it. Having been made refugees during the war of 1948, many Palestinians were robbed of their lands by these laws. In addition, many Palestinian villages had been declared “military zones” by the Israeli army. The owners frequently were living a few miles away, waiting for the military to allow them access to their land, only to have the title stripped from them.

Indirect discrimination is equally insidious: Many social services such as student and housing loans are predicated on having a military service number. Since Palestinians are exempt from military service, few Israeli Arabs have this number. Orthodox Jews are also exempt from military service, but they can go to the military service office and get assigned a number, giving them the same access to the privileges associated with military service. Many help-wanted ads specify that the position is open to candidates “after military service,” another way of saying, “Arabs need not apply.”

Institutional discrimination crops up in community development plans, where Palestinian neighborhoods are held to existing land allocations, while Jewish neighborhoods grow unchecked. In the Arab city of Nazareth, for example, the population of 13,000 Palestinians in 1947 lived on 3,000 acres. In 2007, with a population of 70,000, the city occupies only 3,100 acres, with strict limitations on any expansion.

On the hilltops surrounding it, the mainly Jewish city of Nazareth Illit (built on confiscated Palestinian land) with a population of 50,000, sprawls across 11,250 acres. When the original Palestinian owners of the land went to court to protest the confiscation of their property for “public” purposes, arguing that they were also the public, the court ruled that absorption of immigration was the main “public purpose” of the time.

In 1965, the Israeli parliament adopted the Planning and Construction Law governing development in the country. Dozens of villages were declared “unrecognized” and the land classified as non-residential agricultural land. Some 100,000 Israeli Palestinians live in these villages, which Zeidan says are more aptly called “dis-recognized,” They receive no government services such as electricity, water and sewage, although they pay the same taxes as other citizens, and all structures are considered illegal and subject to demolition.

Municipal funding is also plagued by inequity. In Jerusalem, for example, the population of approximately 700,000 includes 270,000 Palestinians. Social services in mainly Palestinian East Jerusalem receive 12 percent of the city budget. Education in East Jerusalem gets 15 percent of the budget. Per capita income in East Jerusalem is 1,311 shekels per month (or $341), versus 5,968 (or $1,520) in West Jerusalem.

Israel maintains two educational systems, one in Hebrew for Jews and one in Arabic for Palestinians. According to Ittijah, the Union of Arab Community-Based Organizations, 75 percent of Jewish schools have career and vocational guidance services, while only one-quarter of Arab schools do. Government-funded preschools do not operate in Arab towns.

Cultural discrimination flows from the other three forms of discrimination, says the AHR’s Zeidan. Israeli culture is steeped in racism, he says. More than half the population believes that political rights such as voting should be withdrawn from Palestinians living inside Israel. The Ysrael B’tenah Party, which with 12 seats is the fourth largest party in the Knesset, openly speaks of “transfer” of the Palestinian population. “The space that we can act inside Israel is getting smaller and smaller,” says Zeidan.

While Israel is legally a bilingual state — Hebrew and Arabic — you are more likely to encounter signage in Russian or English than in Arabic. ATMs, for instance, are mostly in Hebrew, English and sometimes Russian. Many government offices refuse to conduct business in Arabic.

“Israel is a democratic state for Jews and Jews only,” says Fida Ibrahim Abu Ata, public relations director of Ittijah. “And that is how it should be stated, as plain and vivid as this.”

Ellen Davidson is a longtime Jewish- American peace activist from New York who traveled to Palestine on a delegation with the Middle East Children’s Alliance, mecaforpeace.org.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Sphinn
  • Mixx
For eight years, The Indypendent has printed truth in the face of power. With political and economic systems faltering, there is an opportunity for real change from the bottom up. But this means having a vibrant independent media. Consider supporting The Indypendent as a monthly sustainer, donating as little as $5 a month. Please visit indypendent.org/donate.

Subscribe to the Indypendent!

3 Responses to “Israeli Democracy: Arabs Need Not Apply”

Ali Says:

Many of your facts are grossly exaggerated. It is time to criticize ALL the countries in the region who do not have any democracy AND all of the SYMPATHETIC JEWS who too quickly forget their history.
Over one million Arabs live in Israel, enough said. How many Jews live in Arab countries?
You traveled with an organization that supports children yet not any that are Jewish why? Many live under attack of daily qassam rockets in Sderot for example, destroying their homes, schools and lives… I love people who call themselves ‘peace activists’ and are actually quite the opposite.

Anonymous Says:

I think Ellen Davidson’s critique of Israel’s democracy is spot on and is an issue that does not get brought up much in discussions. Just how democratic is Israel’s government? Not very democratic is you are a Palestinian. Not very democratic if you are GLBT (see Gay Pride counter protests in Jerusalem). This list continues and stops at Jewish Israeli citizen who does not oppose the Israeli goverment’s every move.

Those who offer knee jerk excuses for the Israeli government’s transgressions and crimes often do not address them in substance, as in Ali’s case. They offer emotional appeals and mealy mouthed pronouncements about how Israel’s neighbors are not democratic but their inch deep analysis does not bother to mention how many of those regimes are propped up by the American government (Saudi Arabia, Egypt & Pakistan come to mind, not to mention Iraq).

Furthermore, the Israeli government does little even in the most obvious cases of land theft and crime as detailed in this NYTimes piece below.

Young Israelis Resist Challenges to Settlements
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/12/08/world/middleeast/08westbank.html

Though many of the ultra-Orthodox are certainly barriers to peace, I wonder what the writer Davidson feels are the greatest barriers to any peace settlement, if that is even possible at this moment.

Truthmonger Says:

“Ali” is a zionist troll: no, none of the facts in this article are “exaggerated”. The focus of this piece is Israel, not other countries. Deflecting attention from the issue at hand is a favourite Zionist tactic.

40,000 Jews line in Iran. A Jewish community lives in Lebanon. A hundred years ago, a third of Baghdad was Jewish. Zionists tried many underhand tactics to spirit these indigenous Middle Eastern Jews away to populate the imposed state of Israel.

Let’s not forget that — don’t buy zionist rubbish that they were all expelled by Arab governments.

Leave a Reply