Female Priests Altar the Rules
By Katrin RedfernFrom the December 12, 2008 issue | Posted in National | Email this article
On Nov. 22, Fr. Roy Bourgeois addressed 12,000 people gathered outside Fort Benning, Ga., to protest the Pentagon’s training of Latin American militaries. It was the nineteenth year in a row Bourgeois was present at the School of the Americas Watch demonstration he founded in 1990. But this year was different. It was his first appearance as a layperson, not as a priest.
Bourgeois had recently been excommunicated by the Vatican for participating in the ordination of a woman, Janice Sevre-Duszynska, as a Roman Catholic priest on Aug. 9. At a ceremony in Lexington, Ky., Bourgeois acted as a concelebrant and homilist, the first time “a male Roman Catholic priest in good standing publicly joined the ceremony,” according to the National Catholic Reporter.
Noting that he met Sevre-Duszynska through the School of the Americas Watch movement, Bourgeois said in his homily, “Just as soldiers in Latin America … abuse their power and control others, it saddens me to see the hierarchy of our church abusing their power and causing so much suffering among women. Jesus was a healer, a peacemaker, who called everyone into the circle as equals.”
According to Bourgeois, he received a letter from the Vatican’s doctrinal watchdog group dated Oct. 21, “giving me 30 days to recant my belief and public statements that support the ordination of women in our Church, or I will be excommunicated.”
THE DANUBE 7
Bourgeois’ actions have heightened the visibility of a small, but growing, group of female priests that has emerged since seven women were ordained on the Danube River between Germany and Austria in 2002. The “Danube 7” were ordained by Rómulo Antonio Braschi, an independent bishop who broke with the Catholic hierarchy in the 1970s. It is now estimated that there are about 50 women priests and deacons worldwide and a handful of female bishops. Sevre-Duszynska is one of 35 women in the United States who have been ordained in the past two years.
For Sevre-Duszynska, 58, ordination was the culmination of a lifelong struggle to be treated as an equal in the Catholic Church. Growing up on Milwaukee’s south side, she attended Mass “wanting to hear feminine images of God” and sought to become an altar girl, but instead was given the task of cleaning the dressing room where priests prepared before Mass.
In recent years, Sevre-Duszynska has been arrested for interrupting Catholic ordination ceremonies in several states in order to plead for women’s ordination. She disrupted a Lexington ordination in 1998 to ask then-Bishop J. Kendrick Williams to make her a priest, but he refused. In 2000, she went to a conference in Washington, D.C., where she grabbed the microphone and called for the ordination of women. Two years later she was arrested in Atlanta, Ga., after protesting the ordination of deacons. At these events, Sevre-Duszynska donned priestly robes and a purple stole to symbolize the lost gifts of women.
“If you’re going to refer to God in human terms,” Sevre-Duszynska said to the Indypendent, “you better have a balance of feminine and masculine because … this affects our psychology, our self-esteem, and it creates problems for women and it creates problems for men. It empowers men and disempowers women. It’s not healthy.”
CHURCH POLICY
Catholic Church policy has long insisted that Jesus’ choice of 12 men to be his apostles disqualifies women from the priesthood. Hopes grew during the 1970s that the Vatican would relax its position on female ordination, but the church has remained unbending in its stance throughout the past three decades under the leadership of Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI.
According to Aisha Taylor, executive director of the Women’s Ordination Conference, the oldest and largest organization advocating female priests, the ordination movement began when Catholic women realized they would have to act on their own.
“We’ve tried dialogue, tried to go about it in every other way. We have to go to extreme measures,” Taylor said. “How do we do it differently? How do we change the structures and not just ordain women into the same secretive, nontransparent and unaccountable structure where the clergy sexual abuse crisis was able to happen?”
The women priests movement emphasizes building a more inclusive church and that reforming spirit is evident in its welcoming of priests regardless of their marital status or sexual orientation.
“It wasn’t just adding women and stirring. We incorporate the reforms we’ve been talking about all these years,” said Sevre-Duszynska. “We do not take a vow of obedience to our bishop. It’s not just about getting us ordained.”
For more, see romancatholicwomenpriests.org.
6 Responses to “Female Priests Altar the Rules”
December 13th, 2008 at 8:14 pm
The title said “women altar the rules”. I was a bit disappointed that you focused only on the ordinations and not the alterations being made by the women. The women seek more than ordination. They are deliberately violating the Roman Missal and rubrics for the mass and have been substituting rice crackers, using glass chalices, and attepting bulk consecrations of wine. They state thet aim to eliminate any hierarchy as well.
The RCWP has a much fuller agenda than you have reported. View their photos and read their blogs.
God bless… +Timothy
December 14th, 2008 at 9:43 pm
I think it would be interesting to support women’s ordination on a similar basis used to support the notion of male ordination. Just like the male acts as an Alter Christus/Another Christ, an ordained woman might be justifiable by the notion of “Another Mary”…meaning one who “brings forth” Christ through the Eucharist. It’s an idea I’ve felt open to in the past and even now somewhat.
Still, at the same time I also tend to agree with Timothy…it’s hard to sit down and have sincere dialogue with many of these groups because they tend to dissent from too many Church issues at once (questioning isn’t wrong, and even necessary, if we seek to understand, but this seems more political than faith based). For example, they say they want to be ordained, but also abolish the hierarchy; many of them tend to be pro-choice, etc.
I still have faith the Holy Spirit will guide His Church wherever it needs to be…whether it leads us to having ordained women or not.
December 17th, 2008 at 8:08 pm
I attended the recent RCWP ordination in Chicago and listened to Bishop Dana Rynolds homily with interest. Her strong message of reaching out to all the disenfranchised, the poow, the anawim seemed to be in the best traditionan of the Gospels. At Call To Action I attended the sesssion where five women priest told about their ministeries. I found it impressive and hopeful.
I have over the years worked with women clergy mostly Episcopal and Lutheran and found them to be well educated and dedicated.
The stubborn refusal of our own heiarchy to even seriously debate to ordination of women and their willingness to deprive the Catholic Christian community of the Eucharist in order to maintain male powerseems very contrary to the Lord we serve.
December 27th, 2008 at 3:55 am
RP if you think God guides his church you are lost on 2 counts.
One is that God gave us the free will to choose the direction of his churches,
right or wrong and for which we would ultimately be judged.
Secondly the idea that there is a singular church of God (you said “His Church”) wether it be the the Vatican, Catholic Church or even just all Christian churches
it does a disservice to the scope that God operates on.
To not give women, His creatures access is stupid, merely going back to men owning women nothing else, though they dress it up. There are a lot of ignorant things in the church that need to be changed, so if those priests take on concerns beyond their own rights in the church, it should be taken as more than self-serving. Remember Jesus was a revolutionary not a follower.
December 27th, 2008 at 8:15 pm
Rather than battling a brick wall, composed of the Pope, the College of Cardinals, etc, why not put the time & energy into opening the lay deaconate for women as well??
Those positions are a terminal step, clearly understood by all Catholics NOT to be on the way to the ordained celibate priesthood and may well be needed in the not so far off future…
Then let the example of the married priests in the Roman rite (former Episcopal priests) & the Eastern Rites, both Catholic & Orthodox, convince the Pope & Cardinals that marriage won’t destroy the ordained clergy.
In far too many lands, wracked by war & other oppressions, the Church isn’t loud & making itself a target, but the people cling to their faith & make the best of matters, feeling that God will understand their adaptations…
Think of the centuries of the underground Church in Japan, as well as the Catacombs, & remember that the Koreans built an entire Church for decades on lay leadership before the hierarchy arrived…

































December 12th, 2008 at 2:22 pm
Women have worked for years to find ways to crack the “y chromosome” barrier shielding the Catholic priesthood. The more they try, the more the male hierarchy insists on specious arguments about what Jesus intended. No wonder women have decided to move on without approbation of the hierarchy. Maybe in time the Catholic Church will come to realize how dumb their argument sounds and reach out to women who have better pastoral instincts than men by nature.
Joe Langen, author of Navigating Life: Commonsense Reflections for the Voyage