The Indypendent
DONATE NOW - URGENT FALL 2009 FUNDRAISING CAMPAIGN
Search All Articles

Get The Indy by Email




Facebook Twitter

Donate

Subscribe

The IndyShop

RSS Available

Why we love The Indy






Sarah Stuteville
Journalism Workshops

Indykids

Posters!

A Threat to Peace
Artwork by The Indypendent Staff

A Threat to Peace - Artwork by The Indypendent

Buy Now! »


Army of None
Artwork by David Hollenbach

Army of None - Artwork by David Hollenbach

Buy Now! »


Community Resources

The One That Got Away: A Review of Frozen River

By Judith Mahoney Pasternak
From the February 27, 2009 issue | Posted in Culture , Film | Email this article

At the very northern tip of New York State, far beyond the wealthy counties that surround the Big Apple, winters are bitter cold and the farm economy is long gone, replaced by discount stores and cut-rate malls. It’s poor country, and nowhere is poorer than the area along the wide St. Lawrence River.

The river is the boundary between the United States and Canada — except for one small stretch, near the town of Massena, where the St. Regis Mohawk Reservation straddles the river and international relations are superseded by tribal law. Here, for five dollars, local whites and Indians alike play bingo in the hope of a payoff that will stave off the bill collectors for a little while or even finance a new, double-wide trailer. Here, too, are opportunities for even bigger payoffs from cross-border smuggling enterprises — if the smugglers can evade law enforcement officials who lie in wait just outside the reservation.

And here, in Frozen River, the wrenching — and rivetingly suspenseful — first film by writer-director Courtney Hunt, Ray Eddy (Melissa Leo), one of Upstate’s hard-scrabble whites, wakes up one morning a few days before Christmas to find that her recovering gambler husband Troy has slipped — big-time.

Troy has run off, leaving her with their two sons and taking one car and Ray’s savings for the new double-wide that was due to be delivered Christmas Eve. She goes to the reservation to look for him at the bingo parlor, but finds only the abandoned car, just in time to see a stranger drive it away.

Furious, Ray chases the car down, which is how she meets Lila (Misty Upham), a Mohawk woman in many ways her counterpart. Lila is a widowed mother desperate for money to get back her child, who’s been taken from her by her wealthier Mohawk in-laws. Ray is desperate for four thousand dollars to pay for the new trailer. Lila knows of a smuggling ring that sneaks undocumented immigrants into the Canadian side of the reservation and then offers good money for someone to drive them across the ice of the frozen St. Lawrence and into the United States. Little as Lila trusts white people, she needs someone white to drive the car, so the New York State troopers won’t stop it when it leaves the reservation.

So, very reluctantly, Ray and Lila agree to work together, in the face of formidable odds that include the unreliable and potentially deadly ice they must cross, the troopers waiting if they survive the crossing, and the high likelihood that their employers will pay less than the promised fee if they do arrive with their human cargo. Frozen River is the account of their brief but life-changing partnership.

Movies about women get far fewer Oscar nominations than movies about men, and movies about working-class people get fewer still. True to Academy Award form, Frozen River got little notice from the Oscar nominators, except for Melissa Leo’s performance and Hunt’s screenplay.

I would have given Frozen River both awards, for best actress in a leading role and best screenplay. I would have chosen director of photography Reed Morano’s capture of the bleak junkyard-cluttered winter landscape for the cinematography award.

And finally, instead of Slumdog Millionaire — which took the top award — I would have named Frozen River best picture of 2008.

Share and Enjoy:
  • TwitThis
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Sphinn
  • Mixx
For nine years, The Indypendent has printed truth in the face of power. With political and economic systems faltering, there is an opportunity for real change from the bottom up. But this means having a vibrant independent media. Consider supporting The Indypendent as a monthly sustainer, donating as little as $5 a month. Please visit indypendent.org/donate.

Subscribe to the Indypendent!

5 Responses to “The One That Got Away: A Review of Frozen River”

wow Says:

These movie reviews are an embarrassment to anyone who is from that area. Admittedly there are people who are as poor and desperate as described, but Massena is just a typical small blue collar town. This is the same kind of factory town you will find in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Michigan. A large portion of the population work honest jobs in a factory earning fair wages. Not everyone in the area dreams of a double wide.

JB Says:

I am from Massena and take offense to your portrayal of it. It may be small town rural here but we certainly don’t walk around town with our heads down wondering where our next meal will come from. This is just like every other town in this country, filled with the have and have nots. There are plenty of people with money around here, as well as those with very little. But for you to suggest that we are all well below the poverty line with no hope for anything is just plain ridiculous. Perhaps you should research your material before writing about it.

Judith Mahoney Pasternak Says:

FYI, my research shows that, according to U.S. Department of Agriculture statistics, in 2007 St. Lawrence County was the fourth poorest county in New York State (see www.ers.usda.gov/Data/Unemployment/RDList2.asp?ST=NY).

JB Says:

Instead of going by stats to infer that everyone dreams of a double wide perhaps you should actually visit or maybe actually talk to someone from the area instead of making ignorant assumptions.

have-not Says:

Granted, no one wants to be poor. Also, no one wants to feel that their hometown is the bottom of any thing, statistics aside. But to suggest that we come and visit the town to see the haves, to ignore the conditions of the have-nots, seems misguided.
For a film to show the have-nots and their dreams of double wides could potentially impact this country in its current economic plight in many positive ways. It could implore the haves in your own town to open their eyes and hearts to the have-nots. It could empower the have-nots to tell their stories without needing to romanticize themselves or their situation. It could empower the have-nots all over the country to live their lives with increased dignity, knowing that the reality of our situations are beyond simple class demarcations.
Offense is not an appropriate reaction to a film that portrays the have nots in your hometown. Have nots are everywhere. And it is what it is. Shame is a byproduct of something much larger and more impactful, like institutional classism and a state system that creates pockets of poverty, like JMP has pointed out.

Leave a Reply