The Indypendent
DONATE NOW - URGENT FALL 2009 FUNDRAISING CAMPAIGN
Search All Articles

Get The Indy by Email




Facebook Twitter

Donate

Subscribe

The IndyShop

RSS Available

Why we love The Indy






Sarah Stuteville
Journalism Workshops

Indykids

Posters!

A Threat to Peace
Artwork by The Indypendent Staff

A Threat to Peace - Artwork by The Indypendent

Buy Now! »


Army of None
Artwork by David Hollenbach

Army of None - Artwork by David Hollenbach

Buy Now! »


Community Resources

NYPD’s Racist Tactics Exposed

By Jaisal Noor
From the February 27, 2009 issue | Posted in Local | Email this article

Ten years after the shooting of Amadou Diallo and subsequent public outcry against racial profiling, the New York Police Department continues to disproportionately target blacks and Latinos.

According to the New York Civil Liberties Union and Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) report, the NYPD stopped 543,982 individuals in 2008, more than 80 percent of whom were black or Latino.

Whites, who make up 44 percent of the city’s population, made up only 10 percent of those stopped and questioned.

In the last year of the Mayor Rudolph Giuliani administration, police stopped 86,705 individuals in 2001. The 2008 total represents a 71,886-stop increase from the 2007 total of 472,096 stops and is 15 percent higher than the 2005 to 2007 average of 459,000 stops per year.

The report notes the disparity in frisking after stops: Between 2005 and June 2008, only 8 percent of whites stopped were also frisked, while 85 percent of blacks and Latinos who were stopped were also frisked.

The number of stops is on the rise despite the police’s own data that show that almost 90 percent of those stopped over the past three years were never charged with a crime. Only 2 percent of stops resulted in recovery of weapons or contraband. Furthermore, according to the CCR, “Police stops-and-frisks without reasonable suspicion violate the Fourth Amendment, and racial profiling is a violation of fundamental rights and protections of the Fourteenth Amendment and the Civil Rights Act of 1964.”

While the NYPD continues to deny allegations of profiling based on race, City Council member Charles Barron (D-East New York) told The Indypendent that the data “validates what activists have been saying now for decades: the police are out of control. This report is an important tool to make the case that the police … freely profile, harass and brutalize people. This is real, its not race-baiting that activists are making up.”

TEN YEARS AFTER THE DIALLO KILLING

The Feb. 4, 1999, shooting of Diallo — an unarmed West African immigrant who was killed outside his Bronx home in a barrage of 41 bullets fired by four undercover police officers — galvanized a wave of protests against police brutality of the Giuliani administration. More than 1,700 people, including many of the city’s elected black and Latino officials, were arrested for engaging in acts of civil disobedience.

A subsequent federal investigation concluded the NYPD’s Street Crimes Unit engaged in racial profiling. Public pressure forced the city to officially ban the practice. As part of a case filed by the CCR in response to the Diallo killing, the NYPD was required to keep stop-and-frisk data.

A new lawsuit, Floyd v. The City of New York, was filed in January 2008, and in September a federal judge ordered the police to release all of the past 10 years worth of stop-and-frisk data.

“The vast majority of stops are police initiated,” said CCR Staff Attorney Darius Charney. “Police are in certain neighborhoods and on their own initiative they decide to stop someone.” Charney also said that police data shows the least common reason for an NYPD stop was encountering an individual who fit a description of a suspect.

While Charney states that he doesn’t “want to assume bad intentions on the part of the police,” he argues that, “whatever the motivation, profiling is simply not an effective crime fighting strategy. And its continued use is building a lot of distrust in between police and community.”

Barron believes that the latest stop-and-frisk revelations highlight Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s failings as a city leader.

“Bloomberg has a protectionist policy,” Barron said. “It allows his commissioner to violate the law without reprimanding him or changing policies. The police have set up ‘impact zones’ and Bloomberg has allowed for police containment and harassment instead of job creation or economic development. He chooses to build more prisons and increase police presence while denying economic job creation — 40 to 50 percent of black men in New York City are unemployed.”

The CCR report recommends the NYPD enforce existing reporting requirements and that the city expand the power and the scope of the Civilian Complaint Review Board, which currently investigates complaints of police misconduct, but has no enforcement powers.

For the full CCR report, see ccrjustice.org/criminal-justiceand-mass-incarceration.

Share and Enjoy:
  • TwitThis
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Sphinn
  • Mixx
For nine years, The Indypendent has printed truth in the face of power. With political and economic systems faltering, there is an opportunity for real change from the bottom up. But this means having a vibrant independent media. Consider supporting The Indypendent as a monthly sustainer, donating as little as $5 a month. Please visit indypendent.org/donate.

Subscribe to the Indypendent!

8 Responses to “NYPD’s Racist Tactics Exposed”

taribo Says:

Michael bloomberg is a pure product of wall street. A conservative white male who like
many of his CEO pairs have destroyed the US economy, perpetrated racial and social
injustice against minorities. He used the corrupting power of his money to get elected
and therefore feels like he do not have to respond for the cruelty of his management
malpractices to new yorkers, for it is not normal that whites who make up only 44 percent
of the city represent 90 percent of the NYPD task force. Our only hope resides in the rise of independent newspapers like this one to effectively voice such unbalance and unfairness
and let the peoples’ voices to be heard.
May God be with us

:rolleyes: Says:

I wonder, if in East New York, where there have been five shootings in this past week alone, and the population is over 90% black, why isn’t the NYPD stopping white people in Manhattan? Hmmmmmmmmm…. sounds like racial profiling! Stopping black people in a predominately black area???? RACIST

Jaisal Noor Says:

“The police data shows the least common reason for an NYPD stop was encountering an individual who fit a description of a suspect.”

Matt Says:

Even the rather appalling figure of over 500, 000 people stopped, mostly people of color, per year is probably too low. The police often don’t fill out stop and frisk reports when they stop people. Another really damning indicator of the racial and class nature of policing in NYC are the number of arrests for minor offenses. The number of folks (mostly black or latino) arrested for possession of pot increased 10-fold from 97 to ‘07 over the previous decade, to 400,000 people. Most of those people were arrested for having marijuana on open view despite having it in their pockets or bag, put through the system and then released with a DAT. See: http://www.nyclu.org/node/1736

baltimore Says:

To all of the people who think or say racism is over (we’re a post racial society, we have a black presi) or any other ignorant comments as the like… check the facts.

Racism exists in EVERY single one of our systems. period: (to give a few examples, there are many, many more!)

**SCHOOL SYSTEM- Ask yourself what schools get funded, which are underfunded? How do we measure students’ aptitude (btw..the SAT correlates with income level MORE than any other single indicator (including academic performance in the first year of college). Not to mention which teachers teach in underfunded schools and a host of other things- WHO WRITES THE Curriculums, What do our students learn in school, who’s history???
**Judicial system– checked the sentencing laws lately?
Not to mention poverty! Disporportinately exists all around us and its not just classism….

Sekhem Says:

Please go to freewillieanderson.com, and support this young man that is fighting for his freedom. Racism is permeated within our society. It is a bacteria that is invisible but living everywhere, on on everything.

wolf Says:

I live in nyc and the nypd are a bunch of racist pigs who dont know shit from shinola

Shariq razvi Says:

Nypd is very racist very I need to know who I can contact
I was arrested and for 12 hours they kept me in the prestinct
the arresting officer didn’t even file my papers to the da office
and when my family called they kept on stalling
help me who should I call

Leave a Reply