
As oil continues to spew into the Gulf of Mexico, New York residents worry that a disaster of similar magnitude could happen closer to home.
“The oil and gas industry has increasingly exhausted the easy-toget- to reservoirs,” said Robert Jereski, a New York City environmental activist with the group Safe Water Movement. “This means that most new drilling sites involve much more environmentally dangerous, energy- intensive processes.”
Jereski is just one of the thousands who oppose permitting energy companies to drill for natural gas in deep shale formations in New York using the controversial hydraulic fracturing practice (“hydrofracking”), which uses water, sand and a proprietary cocktail of chemicals under high pressure to crack shale formations to release the gas. Environmentalists continue to organize for a statewide ban on this type of natural gas extraction despite a few recent small victories.
On April 23, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) announced stricter permitting requirements for shale natural gas drilling in the watersheds of Syracuse and New York City. While the extra requirements could result in no new drilling in the Catskills and Skaneateles Lake watersheds, environmentalists and local politicians feel the entire state should be protected.
“A complete ban on watershed drilling was the right thing a year ago, it’s the right thing today,” said Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer in an April 24 press release.
“We’re going to fight them tooth and nail,” Jereski said, “We’ll make an example of any politician or corporate environmental organization who would betray our upstate allies by supporting special protected status for the water downstate, playing into their divide and conquer strategy.”
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency pledged in March to conduct a $1.9 million two-year nationwide study to evaluate the risks to drinking water supplies posed by the hydrofracking extraction process. The Marcellus Shale formation, which extends down to 7,000 feet below ground from New York to Tennessee, is believed to be the world’s largest natural gas reserve. A long list of accidents, explosions, water and air pollution and health complaints have been documented in eight other states where shale fracking is ongoing.
Energy companies are itching to get access to New York reserves. “We have shifted our focus to our next important project, the Marcellus Shale prospect in New York,” said Zoran Arandjelovic, a top executive at Epsilon Energy Ltd., in a May 10 press release about the company’s second quarter earnings. “We are ready to ramp up our operations in New York when the moratorium on conducting hydraulic fracturing for the extraction of natural gas is lifted.”
Environmentalists are supporting two bills in the New York State Assembly. A. 10490 would impose a ban on hydraulic fracturing until 120 days after the findings of the EPA study is released. A. 10633 would give towns the authority to pass local ordinances to regulate gas drilling.
More than 2,800 people have signed an online petition organized by Catskill Mountainkeeper to encourage the DEC to hold off issuing its Final Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement on the Oil, Gas and Solution Mining Regulatory Program until the EPA study is complete. The DEC aims to streamline the environmental review process for new drilling permits.




Comments
This article mixes apples and oranges. An underwater oil spill is completely different and far more devastating in the short run than hydrofracking. The main problem with hydrofracking is not "spills," but long-term, cumulative pollution of the water table with the chemicals. The scale of the gulf oil spill is a number of magnitudes higher than even a worst-case scenario accident in hydrofracking.
Who believes the Marcellus shale formation is "the world's largest natural gas reserve"? There are all sorts of wild estimates, such as Terry Engelder's estimate that it may contain up to 516 trillion cubic feet. But only 10 percent of the that amount is estimated to be recoverable, with estimates ranging from 16.8 to 51.6 TCF of natural gas.
http://www.earthworksaction.org/pubs/OGAPMarcellusShaleReport-6-12-08.pdf
The largest reserves in the world are in Russia, Iran and Qatar. The South Pars/North Dome field shared by Iran and Qatar has an estimated 1,260 trillion cubic feet that is recoverable -- which is 25 to 75 times the Marcellus Shale estimates. And the Marcellus estimates are considered optimistic and even unrealistic.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Pars_/_North_Dome_Gas-Condensate_field
Also, the Marcellus Shale extends up to 9,000 feet down, not 7,000.
Good article, but wish you were more clear about the grimy politicians that are trying ineffectively to foist a two tiered solution, case in point this quote:"“A complete ban on watershed drilling was the right thing a year ago, it’s the right thing today,” said Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer in an April 24 press release." Di d you ask him why? Why drill in NYS at all? How far from the so-called NYC watershed is sfae? ANy distance safe? At least he says ban, without activists pushing and confronting him he'd still be saying "study" and "moratorium".
Add new comment