Blogging from the West Bank: Plus ça Change …
July 27, 2010 | Posted in Ellen Davidson , IndyBlog , Palestine | Email this articleBy Ellen Davidson
There’s a saying in French: Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose—the more things change, the more they stay the same.
There are a few other things around here that haven’t changed much since I was here last. Take the illegal settlements on the West Bank. ICAHD Director Jeff Halper took participants in this year’s summer camp on what he calls the “Matrix of Control” tour last Friday. From the dusty village of Anata, with its potholed dirt roads and no sidewalks, we went to the settlement of Ma’aleh Adumim, a sprawling city of 40,000 with lush green landscaping, three municipal swimming pools, and its own Peace Library.
The area designated for the settlement’s expansion, a 4,000-acre swath known as E1, stretches all the way from Jerusalem to Ma’aleh Adumim, essentially cutting the West Bank in half. Halper explained how the Palestinian Authority is already essentially acquiescing to this bisection; they have contracted with a Japanese company to build roads from Ramallah to Jericho and back across the West Bank to Bethlehem, replacing the traditional route between the two cities, which goes through Jerusalem. The new roads are just another step the in the process of removing Jerusalem from the center of West Bank life.
Work is continuing on two sets of roads on the West Bank: When they are completed, one set will be closed to Palestinians and will serve to connect the settlements that dot the region; the other roads, complete with checkpoints, will be for Palestinian use. Many of the checkpoints are located in underpasses, so that the settlers need never know they are on occupied Palestinian land.
Residents of Ma’aleh Adumim, said Halper, are blissfully unaware that they are part of an Israeli plan to control most of the territory of the West Bank. They move to the settlement, which is called a “neighborhood,” because they can get inexpensive housing only 10 minutes away from Jerusalem and because they want to get away from the increasingly large community of religious Jews (now about 30 percent of the city’s population). “These people have never even heard of ‘E1,’” Halper said.
The green lawns and median strips of Ma’aleh Adumim are incongruous in this desert country. Everything has to be irrigated, since it doesn’t rain here at all during the summer months. Per capita, settlers use on average five times as much water as Palestinians, and many Palestinian villages go without water for several days each week.
Nearby is the Al Aqsa mosque, one of the most important mosques in the Muslim world. Underneath is an archaeological dig. Like most archaeological projects in Jerusalem, the goal is to dig down to the historical period when Jews occupied the city to bolster Zionist claims to the area. In this case, there is an added twist: Jewish settlers have been intentionally digging tunnels without reinforcing the support structure. Their hope is that the next big earthquake (and the region is overdue for one) will bring down the mosque, so that the Jewish Temple on the Mount can be reconstructed in its place.
From Silwan, we went to the Sheikh Jarrah demonstration. I had a feeling of déjà vu as I stood on the street corner I had stood on a year ago, with Israeli and international activists mingling with Palestinians. Things didn’t seem to have changed much in the intervening time. I did notice one new element, however: In the desert below Ma’aleh Adumim construction has begun on an artificial lake for a new water park.
4 Responses to “Blogging from the West Bank: Plus ça Change …”
July 29th, 2010 at 1:17 pm
As an Indy reader (one of many, I suspect) who thinks that coverage of the struggle for a free Palestine is indeed important, I’m grateful for Ellen’s posts from the West Bank and glad that she carves the time to write them out of the long days she’s putting in rebuilding houses under the Mediterranean sun. One wonders what the anonymous reader of the above comment is doing with her/his time that’s as worthwhile.
July 29th, 2010 at 6:30 pm
Thanks to Ellen Davidson not only for writing the above excellent article but also for being out there - not only talking the talk, but walking the walk. Some people, unfortunately, are just good at talking or writing nasty notes while others put themselves literally on the line. And thanks to the Indypendent for it’s great and insightful coverage of the important issues. Keep up the good work and come home safe Ellen!
July 30th, 2010 at 4:23 pm
If you download the latest issue, you can see that AK Gupta is now listed as the “General Manager” of the Indypendent, and there is a “board” consisting of his allies and some woman named Ana Gold (who is she? Is she even a real person?) And of course the cover story is by AK as well, cementing his new status. I guess he can writer the cover every issue now. (It is some turgid political rant).
So I guess this is the new Indypendent. It sucks. What happened to Jessica Lee? Her name is not even on the masthead any more.



































July 28th, 2010 at 7:12 am
I’m glad we are going to get more of this kind of coverage from the Indypendent, now that AK Gupta is Der Commandant of the paper. All his friends will be writing content all the time, covering the same 2 or 3 topics he thinks are important. It’s going to be great.